Tuesday, August 16, 2022
Home Latest News Blockchain News Messy NFT Drop Angers Infosec Pioneers with Unauthorized Portraits

Messy NFT Drop Angers Infosec Pioneers with Unauthorized Portraits

‘I don’t approve of this whatsoever and would like it removed,’ said one subject

An unauthorized NFT drop celebrating infosec pioneers has collapsed into a mess of conflicting takedowns and piracy.

Released on Christmas Day by a group called “ItsBlockchain,” the “Cipher Punks” NFT package included portraits of 46 distinct figures, with ten copies of each token. Taken at their opening price, the full NFT value of the drop was roughly $4,000. But almost immediately, the infosec community began to raise objections — including some from the portrait subjects themselves.

The portrait images misspelled several names — including EFF speech activist Jillian York and OpenPGP creator Jon Callas — and based at least one drawing on a copyright-protected photograph. More controversially, the list included some figures who have been ostracized for harmful personal behavior, including Jacob Appelbaum and Richard Stallman.

Responding on Twitter, York tweeted a link to her own portrait and said simply, “I don’t approve of this whatsoever and would like it removed.”

Removing the NFT has been more complicated than it might seem. The ItsBlockchain team apologized on Twitter for not obtaining likeness rights in advance and said it has removed 28 NFTs from the group and burned two others. But there’s no clear procedure for removing tokens that have already been sold, and ItsBlockchain is mostly counting on the central OpenSea platform to remove the tokens and resolve the issue. ItsBlockchain has appealed to the platform for guidance, but so far it has received little guidance. (OpenSea did not respond to a request for comment.)

“We have been trying to resolve this issue … we want to take it down,” the group said in an email to The Verge. “OpenSea involvement would make the job easy at this stage.”

The incident is a reminder of the potentially thorny legal issues around NFTs, where norms of permissionless innovation often clash with likeness rights and intellectual property law. Typically, US laws around publicity rights hold that a person’s name and identity can’t be used for promotion without their consent — although it’s unclear how such a lawsuit would work in practice when applied to NFTs.

Source: The Verge


About Skyhigh.Vip  

Skyhigh.Vip is a global institutional investor with a vast interest in Arts / Construction / Education / Business Services / E-Sports and various other growth industries.  

Several of its popular portfolios include GO Chambers which is the world’s largest business chamber listing provider with over 30,000 active chambers as its members.  

Flexgigzz is the Asia leading marketplace for freelancers service and together with SOHO Learning Hub which is an online platform for short courses and both of them aims to be the number one provider in Asia. For growth industries such as E-Sport Authority which is dedicated to providing independent media coverage to all E-Sport News related from around the world and for the art world, there is Atelier Auction which is an investable art auctioneer and being in the art scene for decades.

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

DTI: There Is No Exact Rules Of Crypto

DTI or The Philippine Department of Trade and Industry waved off a Binance ban proposal, Due to the lack of regulatory stance on cryptocurrencies from...

ATM Installations Of Crypto Will Dominated By U.S.

ATM Installations Of Crypto Will Dominates By U.S. U.S. dominates crypto due to China our from the competition The US picked up the slack to become...

Indian Taxes Increase, Companies Decrease Amount Of Employee

Indian taxes increase! India's new cryptocurrency tax has dealt a heavy blow to the crypto exchanges in the country, A moment ago, an announcement related to...

Riot Blockchain Moves Their Miner To Texas

Riot Blockchain the Crypto mining firm start relocating their rigs Moving from its New York data facility, With the majority intended to end up in central...

Bitmex Banned Russians From Their Platforms

BitMEX is major cryptocurrency exchange It aims to increase compliance with the European sanctions against Russia By preparing to enforce major restrictions for its Russian users. Then...

ECB Officials Will Consider Newest Crypto Law

ECB officials will get ready for crypto growth As crypto grown so fast, Many countries started to prepare anything related to the digital assets Regulators from 19...

Rumors KuCoin Bankrupt, CEO Gives A Statement

KuCoin is a crypto exchange that used by many users these few times As we know that the line's condition these days shows not really...

U.S. Lawmakers: There Is Inequality In Crypto Industry

U.S. Lawmakers seeing a problem A problem in crypto industry development According to some U.S. lawmakers in the House Financial Services Committee, The lack of diversity in...

Grayscale Investments File Disapproved, CEO Disappointed

Grayscale Investments launched a legal challenge It against the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Previously, they are denied to convert their application From Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) Into...